Short sighted


Myopia is the medical term for being short sighted, where someone can see those things immediately before them with clarity and yet distant objects appear blurred.

Humanity has struggled with mental myopia for thousands of years.

It’s natural to think we have 20:20 vision, but we only see a fragment of reality. Take for example the concept of sunrise and sunset. Almost five hundred years have passed since the Copernican Revolution, when an obscure Polish astronomer developed a mathematical model to describe the orbit of the planets, placing the sun at the center of the solar system.

What made Copernicus notable, wasn’t his theory, it was how he derived his theory. His calculations were no less complex than those of Ptolemy and his Earth-centric view of the universe, but the model proposed by Copernicus required less assumptions and naturally explained key points, like why Mercury and Venus never strayed far from the Sun.

ptolomey_solar_s_1

In this Ptolemaic representation, Earth is at the center, with the first orbit occupied by Luna (the Moon), the second by Mercury, the third by Venus, and the forth by Sol (the Sun). Copernicus realized numerous inconsistencies with this model could be resolved by considering the Sun as the center of the solar system.

The Copernican Revolution was the triumph of reason over the senses. For the first time, logical inference was more important than casual observations. To this day, we still speak of sunrise and sunset even though no such event ever occurs: Earth turns. Our senses tell us we’re stationary and that it’s the sun that moves during the course of a day, but we’ve learned not to trust our senses. We trust the scientific description of reality over what we see.

Regardless of whether we’re looking at stars in the sky or birds in a tree, we don’t see reality for what it is, we see but a snapshot in time, just a thin sliver of reality, a fragment of a larger story.

Look out at the stars and you’re looking back in time.

What were you doing eight years ago? Where were you living? How old were your kids (if you have any)? What job did you have eight years ago? Because, walk outside tonight and stare up at the sky and chances are the brightest star you will see is Sirius, and the light that falls on your eyes left Sirius eight years ago.

Out of the top 100 brightest stars in the evening sky, 80 of them are over 60 light years away, meaning the light we see from them is older than the majority of people reading this post. Catch a glimpse of Andromeda, and you’re seeing light that originate well over a million years before Homo sapiens arose as a species, and yet the view seems so sedate, so rudimentary, so commonplace and unassuming.

Like someone with myopia, we think we see clearly, but without science we only ever see a fleeting glimpse of reality, an oversimplification.

Another example of mental myopia can be found in creationism.

Creationists think of species as being formed independent of each other over just a couple of days, a few thousand years ago. In reality, every species we see is an extension of the most ancient forms of life branching out in endlessly varied forms. We tend to think of species as fixed, settled, but they are plastic and malleable, constantly adapting for a variety of natural reasons.

timeline-of-hominid-evolution_517f2065cdb2b

Biological life is in a constant state of flux, adapting and evolving before us, but at a rate that makes the motion of a glacier seem like a bush fire racing across a grassy plain. The animals we see today are simply the latest forms, not the final forms of life on Earth.

Creationist often ask, “If evolution is true, show me the transition species. Show me the missing links.” But the question fails to realize that every species is in transition, including our own.

It’s no wonder creationists think this way, as we naturally have mental myopia. With our five senses, we observe just the fleeting fragment of the vast reality before us, missing the depth of all that transpired over billions of years to bring us to this point.

As for, “Show me the missing links,” stop and think about that for a moment. How far back can you trace your family tree? Can you reach back as far as the Declaration of Independence? How about the reign of Elizabeth the First, or Julius Ceasar? Show me your missing links, prove to me that you really are a member of the human race and not the pedigree of some alien replicant sleeper cell. I’m being silly, but you get the point. The proof lies in that you’re here. To get here, you must have an unbroken chain of parentage, one that spans back not hundreds or even thousands of years, not millions or even hundreds of millions of years, but billions of years.

In theory, there could be a species alive today for which there is no fossil evidence at all (I don’t know of one, but it’s possible), and yet that this species exists tells us there is an unbroken lineage, whether we see it or not. That we don’t see it says more about our lack of vision than it does about that species’ pedigree.

Whether we are considering quarks or electrons, viruses or bacteria, whether we are looking out into the furthest reaches of space or at animals in a zoo, science has allowed us to see reality for what it is, exposing the hidden depth behind what we see with our eyes.

Science isn’t perfect, but it is self-correcting, providing us with a clear lens with which to see the universe.

The challenge that faces humanity moving into the future is to avoid being short-sighted.

About these ads

9 thoughts on “Short sighted

  1. Even those who should know better occasionally fall victim to “It Has Always Been Thus”-itis. Physicists and astronomers believed the stars were fixed in the sky since they didn’t appear to move even after several generations. They thought the universe was eternal, static, and that time had no beginning. And they should have known better, because they knew gravity had to be acting on the stars, pulling them together. Einstein invented the Cosmological Constant to fudge his work so it would be consistent with a static universe.

    Then Edwin Hubble came along, showed us that the universe is expanding, and scientists everywhere did a facepalm.

    Good times.

  2. I had a conversation with a missionary in Mongolia while I was there about evolution. It was so very evident that she had no clue about the subject, since she asked “So you’re basically saying that a dog can over time turn into a human”. I think it’s another misconception of creationists that there is only 1 line in which living organisms evolve. She also said “The ideas that you harbor are dangerous (to your faith)”. And as a Christian, I must actually say that her ideas are much more dangerous to faith because after studying little (and I would say I only studied it a little) it’s clear that evolution is true, and if as a Christian Creationist you say that either Evolution is wrong or the bible is wrong, then the bible must be wrong. Which is how many Christian children who grow up being taught creationism feel as they’re learning these things in school. Genesis, like much of the old testament are meant to explain generally in a story of what happened, and to take that literally word for word is foolish.

    Though the bible does have a lot of accounts that are historically proven, I would say that the major difference between scientific evidence and evidence of a God is that the evidence for God must be personal (though you scientific guys would say that isn’t evidence at all), but without that personal evidence I really don’t think you can have faith. And the “science” of Creationism which is largely based on personal evidence (which relate to matters of faith and not actually evidence for creationism) isn’t really science.

    • Good on you. It’s a courageous mind that dares to think.

      I like your point that “her ideas are much more dangerous,” as you’re absolutely right. Our world has changed for the better with the advent of scientific knowledge. To surrender this knowledge and revert to concepts like creationism would be extremely dangerous, undoing so much good that’s been accomplished over the past few hundred years.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s